Welcome to Mr. Pizza East Rutherford
Mr. Pizza East Rutherford is a culinary gem located at 118 Carlton Ave, East Rutherford, NJ. Renowned for its exceptional pizza, this establishment has garnered rave reviews from satisfied customers who praise its delectable dishes and warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Patrons like "R M" and "MoOk RuLz" have hailed the pizza as some of the best they've ever tasted, highlighting the perfect crust and rich flavor profile that keeps them coming back for more. The welcoming staff enhances the dining experience, making it an ideal spot for family celebrations or casual outings. Whether you're craving a classic cheese slice or flavorful wings, Mr. Pizza promises an unforgettable meal.
Mr. Pizza East Rutherford: Reviews & Ratings
Simply Amazing! We went there to celebrate my daughter’s 9th birthday after leaving American Dream mall. The food is amazing! Pizza amazing! Best pizza I have ever eaten! This place is truly a hidden gem! Wings amazing! Nice family atmosphere, very welcoming staff, great service, left us blown away! We’re still talking about it. Extremely satisfying experience! We will definitely be back! Thank you Mr Pizza!
Drove an hour to try their pizza. Definitely worth the drive! Kids loved the pizza and their hospitality was very warm and welcoming! We will definitely be back!
Of all the pizza joints around this area I gotta say this joint has the best tasting pizza. I speak only for the regular cheese slice cause thats all I usually get . The crust is perfect and its just a great slice.
Best pizza in the area!! nice people and nice place too
The Beat pizza I’ve had in years. If you want a great plain slice of pizza go here.
One of the best pizzas in the area
If you're rounding up the little ones after school and looking for the perfect pit stop before hitting the playground, Mr. Pizza in East Rutherford is the place to be! It's a hit with the kids, especially their pizza margherita—voted #1 by the toughest critics: the children themselves! Don't just take my word for it, though; check out these lively pics of our post-school pizza party!
This is the only pizza my daughter will eat. She doesn’t like any other and we tried many different spots. The crust is always crispy and delicious while the cheese isn’t overwhelming the taste of the sauce. It really is a perfect combination.
Location
-
118 Carlton Ave, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, United States Hotline: +1 551-389-0970
If you're on the lookout for a pizza slice that transcends the ordinary, let me introduce you to a true gem nestled in East Rutherford, New Jersey: Mr. Pizza East Rutherford. Located at 118 Carlton Ave, this cozy establishment is making a name for itself in the vibrant New Jersey food scene. With glowing reviews from satisfied customers, it seems Mr. Pizza is not only about pizza; it embodies a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back for more.
Locals and visitors alike rave about the delectable offerings at Mr. Pizza. One enthusiastic customer, R M, shared how the restaurant became the backdrop for a special celebration. "The food is amazing! Pizza amazing! Best pizza I have ever eaten!" spoke volumes about their experience. It’s what many describe as a “hidden gem”—the perfect spot to enjoy mouthwatering pizza fresh from the oven. With perfectly crafted crusts and rich, flavorful toppings, it's no wonder guests leave with full stomachs and happy hearts.
The excitement doesn’t stop at pizza; the wings have earned accolades too! As one reviewer put it, "Wings amazing! Nice family atmosphere, very welcoming staff." A signature element of Mr. Pizza’s charm is its genuine hospitality, creating a space where families can relax and indulge in delightful culinary creations.
Notably, the crowd favorite seems to be the classic cheese slice. MoOk RuLz’s sentiments resonate with many: "Of all the pizza joints around this area, I gotta say this joint has the best tasting pizza." The perfect amount of seasoning paired with a flawless crust creates a harmonious blend of flavors that are hard to resist. Another satisfied customer, Shana Reed, claims that the hour-long drive to indulge in this pizza was “definitely worth it”—an endorsement that speaks to the quality and consistency of their fare.
In a world where pizza shops abound, Mr. Pizza East Rutherford stands out with its commitment to excellent customer service and delicious food. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a slice of their acclaimed pizza, you’ll find a welcoming haven at Mr. Pizza. As Lorenzo Antonio Urbano Cruz succinctly puts it, "Best pizza in the area!! nice people and nice place too." So why wait? Make your way to East Rutherford and experience the culinary treats that await you at this beloved establishment.